Best Organic Baby Pacifier 2023

Last updated on April 24th, 2023 at 02:46 pm

Are you looking for the best non-toxic, organic baby pacifier for your little one? Our list has your covered with an easy to navigate comparison table of the top brands.

Baby with mother and pacifier
Photo by Sean Roy on Unsplash

Pacifier, paci, binky, dummy, soother, soothie, or whatever else you call them in your household, some babies love them and need them. We as parents love them for the momentary silence they can bring to our overworked ears. They also have medical benefits. They reduce the risk of SIDS (sudden infant death syndrome), so when your adorable little one is fast asleep in their non-toxic crib, you can rest well knowing they are safe.

Most experts agree that pacifiers are okay for babies starting at 3 or 4 weeks old. When they recommend weaning the baby off the pacifier differs. SIDS is most common during the first 6 months of one’s life, so after 6 months, the increased risk of middle ear infections associated with pacifier use might outweigh health benefits.

For certain babies, sucking on a pacifier seems like the only way they can be soothed sometimes, so if your child continues using a pacifier well after 6 months, we aren’t judging. If your child is still using a pacifier after 3 years of age, there is risk of dental problems.

We won’t go to in depth on all of the pros and cons of pacifier use, we just wanted to touch on a few main points. Before we jump into the best organic baby pacifier list, there are a few brief topics one should understand before making their decision.

Table of Contents

Things to Know Before Choosing a Pacifier

Parents often put lots of time into selecting the best organic diapers or best organic baby shampoo, and overlook the pacifier purchase. Most babies spend a lot of time with their pacifier in their mouths. Pacifiers are supposed to be replaced every 4-6 weeks, so even if you only use one pacifier at a time and are able to wean your baby by the age of 1, that is still around 10 pacifiers.

In reality, most parents keep binkies in arms reach so they are prepared to stop an outburst at any moment. Also, many kids use binkies well past one year of age. So most parents can expect to purchase around 30 pacifiers for each child. Once a baby falls in love with one type of pacifier, it is difficult, or sometimes impossible, to get them to change. So choosing the right one at the beginning is of the upmost importance.

Some parents are afraid of giving their baby a toxic pacifier that will cause adverse health complications. Pacifiers, like all products that are designed or intended primarily for children 12 years of age or younger, must be tested by an accredited and CPSC-accepted, third party laboratory for compliance with the pacifier regulation and all other applicable children’s product safety rules.

These tests have the following maximum chemical limits:

  • Surface Coating Limit Pacifiers may not be painted with paint that contains more than 0.009 percent lead.
  • Lead Content Limit Pacifiers cannot contain greater than 100 ppm (0.01 percent) of total lead content in any accessible component part.
  • Phthalate Content Limits Plasticized components of pacifiers must not contain more than 0.1 percent of the following eight specified phthalates: di-(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate (DEHP), dibutyl phthalate (DBP), or benzyl butyl phthalate (BBP), diisononyl phthalate (DINP), diisobutyl phthalate (DIBP), di-n-pentyl phthalate (DPENP), di-n-hexyl phthalate (DHEXP), and dicyclohexyl phthalate (DCHP).

If you are okay with the above safety standards set by the consumer protection safety commission, then any Pacifier on the market will do. Obviously, not all pacifiers are created equal. If you are reading this, we can assume that you understand that overuse of plastic is a huge problem plaguing our environment.

Pacifiers that contain plastics should be avoided at all costs. The best organic baby pacifiers are made from either silicone or natural rubber. Unfortunately, neither rubber or silicone decomposes quickly, although they can both be recycled. Lets quickly discuss the pros and cons of each.


Organic baby pacifiers made of rubber might be the most eco-friendly option. The rubber tree exudes a latex sap, the world’s primary source of natural rubber, which is tapped in a similar manner to maple syrup from a maple tree. After about 20-25 years the tree stops producing latex sap. The trees are then harvested and replanted. The harvested wood is used extensively in furniture, flooring, construction and even toys.

While these trees are producing latex they are also removing carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and reducing the greenhouse gas effect. Lets look at some of the pros and cons of rubber pacifiers.


  • Rubber is typically softer than silicone and more elastic, closer mimicking a real nipple.
  • Production of the material is better for the environment that silicone


  • Not a durable as silicone
  • More difficult to clean than silicone
  • Might have slight odor or taste
  • Could potentially cause allergic reactions to any babies with family history of latex allergies.


Maybe because they look and feel so similar, many people mistakenly think silicone and plastics are one in the same. Silicone does not contain petrochemicals and are in fact, derived from two of the most abundant materials on earth: sand and quartz.

Silicone is definitely not as bad for the environment as plastics, but it still needs to be mined and is not biodegradable. There are some benefits of non toxic pacifiers made of silicone.


  • Very durable and won’t break down as quick as rubber
  • Hypoallergenic, odorless, and tasteless
  • Easy to clean, can be sterilized in boiling water or the microwave


  • More rigid than an actual nipple or rubber pacifier
  • Material must be mined

Now that you have a decent base knowledge of what to look for, lets jump into our best organic baby pacifier list. The table below should help you easily sort through the features that are most important to you.

Chicco Physioforma$10.994.61274.5Silicone

Organic Baby Pacifiers Made of Rubber

Hevea Pacifiers

Hevea brand organic baby pacifier.

We had to start out our best organic baby pacifier list with Hevea brand pacifiers. At $9.99 they are the most affordable rubber pacifier on our list. From the picture, this pacifier looks like it could be two pieces, making it a choking hazard, but rest assured it is one solid piece.

This Certified B Corp makes all of their pacifiers from natural rubber, sourced from a Forest Stewardship Certified® plantation, on the border between Malaysia and Thailand. Partnering with Tree Nation, they will plant a Hevea tree for every purchase over 60 Euros and for any purchases of their LOOP menstruation cups.

As mentioned earlier, although rubber is natural, it still takes at least 50 years to decompose. Hevea started an upcycling program to repurpose their used pacifiers into other useful houshold items to give them a second life. Customers can send their old pacifiers back to the company, and receive 1% store credit.

This organic baby pacifier brand even uses eco-friendly packaging. They use paper packaging that is FSC Certified, meaning it comes from responsibly managed forests. Hevea checks all the boxes for what we look for in a great non toxic baby pacifier and we are proud to have them on our list.

Natursutten Orthodontic pacifier

Natural rubber baby pacifier.

Natursutten Orthodontic pacifier costs $11.99, which is the most expensive on our best organic baby pacifier list. It is made in Italy, so if you think it isn’t extremely eco-friendly you can Fuhgettaboutit.

They care about sustainability and fair trade, so they donate to the Malaysian Rubber Board to support and urge a sustainable industry. The money is used to replant rubber trees and invest in research & development to ensure a sustainable future for the rubber plants in Malaysia.

The company’s environmental goals are to be 100% supplied by renewable energy and to create zero waste to reduce their carbon footprint. They are headed in that direction with Eco-friendly packaging made from paper certified by the Forest Stewardship Council and printed with natural soy ink. Even the clear window is made of bioplastic – from corn, not petroleum.

These natural pacifiers come in three sizes and two types of nipples (rounded or orthodontic).

ecopiggy eco pacifier

ecopiggy brand eco friendly natural baby pacifier.

Eco pacifier by ecopiggy is sustainably made in Malaysia from 100% natural rubber. It is molded into one piece, so it is a safe choice. The average rating for this organic baby pacifier is 4.2, which isn’t that bad, but is the lowest rated on our list.

The main complaint about this natural pacifier is that it has an overpowering rubber smell. The other most common complaints are that it is too large and that the nipple is collapsible. On the other hand, many parents said that his is the only pacifier that their babies will take and they love how soft it is.

They earn the name eco pacifier, with 100% plastic free shipping. They realize that parents are often too busy to remember to order a new pacifier every 4-6 weeks, so they offer 15% off if you sign up for your natural pacifiers to be auto shipped.

Organic Baby Pacifiers Made of Silicone

Chicco Physioforma Silicone Orthodontic Pacifier

Chicco brand physioforma pacifier

We will start the made from silicone section, of our best organic baby pacifier list, off with Chicco Physioforma Silicone Orthodontic Pacifier. More known for their highly regarded strollers and car seats, they also make a fabulous non toxic pacifier.

It is clinically developed, tested, and approved in partnership with an advisory panel of leading neonatologists, pediatricians, and orthodontists. The babies breathing is actively supported by ventilation holes for air circulation that also prevents the gathering of saliva. This silicone pacifier is brilliantly designed to be safe and effective, but we also added it to our best organic baby pacifier list because of some of the social and eco-friendly corporate initiatives Chicco is involved with.

Usually, when you think of large companies, you think of big polluters that only care about bottom lines, but that is not the case with Chicco. Many of their products are GreenGuard Gold Certified. They have created their own material, Chicco Clear Tex, that are developed with innovative textiles that eliminate the need for chemical treatments added to the fabrics—all without compromising safety, sustainability or comfort.

They work with ISO 9001 and ISO 14001 certified factories, showing their commitment to environmental management systems and innovative business practices. They are also committed to making family life better and partner with a number of organizations that help under privileged families.

Nanobebe Pacifiers

Nanobebe brand organic baby pacifiers.

Nanobebe Pacifiers are the highest rated and most reviewed organic baby pacifiers on our list, at 4.7 rating out of 4513 reviews. Not only does this non toxic pacifier have the highest ratings, it is also the least expensive. At just $5.49 each, they are half the price as most of the competition.

The founders are dads and biomedical engineers, so it is no wonder they were able to design award winning pacifiers and bottles. Their Nanobébé bottle is said to be the first baby bottle designed to preserve essential breastmilk nutrients by enabling rapid heating and cooling through an innovative geometric shape.

These engineering marvels have an ergonomic design that curves comfortably around your baby’s nose and chin to stay in place and prevent it from falling out. The one piece, medical grade silicone construction has built in vents to allow airflow.

These incredibly designed organic baby pacifiers are extremely popular, but it should be noted that we were unable to find any information about social responsibility or green corporate initiatives. So if you care more about affordability and great design, this might be the best pacifier for you. If you want to use your dollars to support companies that are actively trying to preserve our environment and make the world a better place, there are better options on our best organic baby pacifier list.


Regardless of the natural pacifier you choose in the end, the fact that you are researching the best pacifiers says a lot of positive things about you as a caregiver. We hope you enjoyed our best organic baby pacifier list. If you found it informative or helpful, please don’t hesitate to share it with others that may benefit. Thank you!

Leave a Comment